Bookish Gifts for Your Best Friend: Matching, Personalized, and Thoughtful Ideas

an image showing someone receiving a gift box from their best friend that is full of bookish items

The best gifts for a best friend who loves to read show that you know their reading life: a mystery book picked from their favorite genre, a bookmark for the exact trope they can't get enough of, a matching keychain so you both carry a piece of your friendship, or a stationery set personalized with their name. Because you know your best friend better than almost anyone, you can skip generic "book lover" gifts and choose something that feels made for them.

Gifts for friends are having a big moment this season, from "Friendsmas" parties to matching best-friend gifts and personalized presents. If your best friend is a reader, you're in luck: bookish gifts are easy to personalize and fun to match. This guide sorts gift ideas by the kind of reader your friend is, then covers personalized gifts, matching sets you can share, and a few Friendsmas ideas.

How to Choose a Bookish Gift for Your Best Friend

You already know more than you think. Before you shop, run through a few quick questions:

  • What do they read most? Romance, fantasy, thrillers, horror? Genre is the easiest way to narrow down a gift.

  • Do they have a favorite trope? Enemies to lovers, small-town romance, hockey romance? A trope-specific gift shows you've been listening to their book rants.

  • Paper or Kindle? A Kindle reader will love accessories for their e-reader. A paper reader might prefer bookmarks and annotation supplies.

  • Do they annotate or journal? Tabs, highlighters, washi tape, and stickers are perfect for readers who decorate their books or journals.

  • What's their aesthetic? Pastel and cute, dark and gothic, cozy and floral? Matching a gift to their style makes it feel personal.

  • What do they already own? Avoid books unless you can be sure they haven't read them. That's where a blind date with a book helps (more on that below).

Gifts by the Kind of Reader Your Best Friend Is

For the Friend You Swap Book Recommendations With

A Blind Date With a Book is a wrapped mystery book chosen by genre, so neither of you knows the title until it's unwrapped. It's a fun gift for the friend who's always telling you what to read next, because this time you get to surprise them.

MIL's blind dates come in nine genres: Romance, Fantasy, Romantasy, Thriller, Mystery and Detective, Horror, Sci-Fi, Contemporary Fiction, and Surprise Me.

The Basic bundle includes a brand-new wrapped book, 5 bookish stickers, a highlighter, a pen, a tea bag, 5 annotation tabs, a paperclip bookmark, 2 handmade MIL bookmarks, and a book tracker bookmark. The Deluxe bundle adds more stickers, a second tea bag, a leather heart bookmark, a magnetic bookmark, a scrunchie, and a color-matched handmade keychain.

The best-friend advantage: When you order a blind date as a gift, you can list a few books your friend loved and a few they didn't, along with preferences like favorite tropes. You can also share a link to their reading profile if it's public and up to date. Nobody knows your friend's taste better than you do, so the more you share, the better the match.

For the Romance Reader

Every romance reader has a trope they'd follow anywhere. The Soda Can Style Romance Trope Bookmarks let you pick theirs. These handmade, laminated, die-cut bookmarks are shaped like soda cans, and each one is labeled for a different kind of reader:

  • Small Town Romance Reader, in warm brown and orange

  • The Witch and The Hunter Reader, in deep purple

  • Hockey Romance Reader, in bold blue

  • Enemies to Lovers Reader, in red

  • Cowboy Romance Reader, in burnt orange and brown

You can choose a single design or the set of all five.

For the friend who cancels plans to finish a book, the Book Boyfriend Hook Bookmark says it for them. Its printed focal bead reads "Sorry I Can't, I Have a Date With My Book Boyfriend," with soft pink silicone beads and a rhinestone spacer on a slim, ornate silver-toned hook that slips between the pages.

For the Hockey Romance Fan

If your best friend has been living in hockey romance all year, the Hockey Romance Themed Bookmarks were made for them. There are three handmade laminated designs, about 2 by 6 inches, all in shades of blue: "If It's Not Hockey I Don't Want It" with hockey skates, "I Like My Men Icy" with a player silhouette and puck, and "In My Hockey Romance Era" with snowflakes and a hockey-couple silhouette. Buy one or the set of all three, with or without a coordinating tassel.

For the Fantasy or Romantasy Reader

For a big gift, the Dragon Fantasy Themed Bookish Bundle is built for readers who love dragons, dangerous kingdoms, and forbidden magic. In black, burgundy, antique gold, deep red, and parchment tones, it includes:

  • A dragon fantasy journal

  • 4 MIL handmade art prints and 2 art print strips

  • 2 dragon fantasy sticker sheets, plus 8 stickers and a ticket-style sticker set

  • 2 MIL handmade bookmarks, a metal bookmark, a magnetic heart bookmark, and a leather heart bookmark

  • 6 small paperclip-style bookmarks

  • A fantasy keychain

  • A highlighter, 4 pens, 3 washi tape strips, and a book review sticky note

For a smaller fantasy gift, the Fantasy Bookish Book Club Bundle matches every piece to one color and includes several bookmarks, five-color annotation tabs, a pastel pen and highlighter, an art print, scratch-off TBR cards, and a fantasy sticker set. The Fantasy Sword Bookmark With Dangling Charms is a metal sword-shaped bookmark that rests above the page with charms hanging over the side, in gold-tone or silver-tone. If your friend loves the knights-and-castles side of fantasy, our guide to the castlecore aesthetic for readers has more ideas.

For the Friend Who Annotates Everything

If your best friend's books are full of colorful tabs, the Book Club Bookish Bundle and Reading Accessories is a great small gift. Every piece coordinates with the color you choose (pink, blue, purple, or green). It includes a handmade laminated bookmark, a book tracker bookmark, a magnetic bookmark, a butterfly magnetic bookmark, 5 annotation tabs, a scratch-off TBR card with a sticker, a tea bag, a paperclip-style bookmark, a pen, a highlighter, and 3 bookish stickers. Our guide to color-coding annotation tabs makes a nice companion.

A flat-lay arrangement of pastel purple and lavender stationery items on a cream fabric background, including a bookshelf planner page, sticky notes, a scratch-off note, a butterfly sticker, a pen, and other book-themed accessories.

For the Friend Who Lives on Their Kindle

For a Kindle reader, look at MIL's Kindle Bookish Bundles. Each one pairs a Kindle insert with a coordinating handmade keychain, a dust plug charm, and stickers. Inserts are cut to specific Kindle models, so check which model your friend has before ordering. Not sure how inserts work? Here's what a Kindle insert is and how it works.

For the Friend Who Loves Cute Things

For the friend whose desk is full of pastel stationery, the Kawaii Stationery Bundle is packed with cute pieces, including a capybara keychain, a gummy bear stackable pencil, a stamp roller pen, washi tape, stickers, and a handmade MIL kawaii bookmark. See more cute ideas in our guide to kawaii gifts for book lovers.

For the Cat-Loving Reader

If your best friend always has a cat on their lap while they read, the Black and White Cat Dangle Earrings are a mismatched pair: one black cat and one white cat, each a cartoon-style enamel charm with big eyes and a curled tail, on gold-tone fishhook ear wires. Pair them with the Cat Notepad Stationery Book Club Bookish Bundle, which includes a cat-themed notepad with a fully magnetic back, a handmade MIL bookish keychain with a tassel, a pen, a highlighter, a scratch-off TBR card, a scratch-off sticker, and three bookish stickers.

Personalized Bookish Gifts for Your Best Friend

A personal touch is what turns a nice gift into a best-friend gift. A few ways to do it:

A name on their stationery. The Ocean Themed Stationery Bookish Bundle includes a pencil pouch you can personalize with your friend's name in heat-printed vinyl. Just type the name in the personalization box exactly as you'd like it to appear. The bundle also includes a handmade blue fabric-covered notebook with sequin designs, a handmade ocean-themed keychain with enamel charms, 5 hand-cut ocean stickers, 5 pens, 2 highlighters, 2 laminated bookmarks, a magnetic bookmark, 10 annotation tabs, binder clips, a book tracker bookmark, and organic blueberry white tea.

A book picked just for them. A blind date with a book becomes personal when you fill in the reading preferences with what you know about your friend: the books they couldn't stop talking about, the ones they didn't finish, and the tropes they love or avoid.

An annotated copy of your favorite book. This is one of the most meaningful bookish gifts you can give. Pick a book you love and want your friend to read, then annotate it for them: tab your favorite lines, write notes in the margins about why a scene made you think of them, and leave little reactions they'll find as they read. Any of the bundles above with annotation tabs and a highlighter give you the supplies.

A handwritten "why I chose this" note. Tuck a short note into any gift explaining why you picked it: the trope you know they love, the color that reminds you of them, or the book you think they'll finish in one night.

Matching Gifts for You and Your Bookish Best Friend

Matching gifts are a sweet way to celebrate a friendship, especially with a fellow reader. Some easy ideas:

  • Matching keychains in different colors. The Beaded Flower Keychain comes in Pink and Cream, Beige and Black, or Pink and White, so you can each choose your own color in the same design. Clip them to your book bags. Our guide to styling a tote bag with charms has placement ideas. For the fantasy fans, check out the gothic sword keychain pictured above.

  • Split a bookmark set. The Masquerade Ball Romantic Trope Bookmark Set comes with two handmade laminated bookmarks, "Hidden in Plain Sight" and a romantic masked couple, so you can each keep one. The Soda Can trope set works the same way: keep your trope, and give your friend theirs.

  • Coordinating bundles. Order two Book Club Bookish Bundles in different colors (one pink and one purple, for example) so you each get a matching set in your own favorite shade.

  • Read together. Buy two blind dates in the same genre and unwrap them together on a video call or at a sleepover. Or pick the same book and do a buddy read, each with your own matching bookmark.

Friendsmas Ideas for Book-Loving Friends

If your friend group celebrates Friendsmas, a few bookish ways to make it special:

  • A blind date exchange. Everyone brings a wrapped book with a few hint words written on the front, and you take turns choosing.

  • A trope-themed white elephant. Everyone brings a small gift themed around their favorite trope, like a trope bookmark, a sticker set, or a book.

  • A matching keychain for everyone. Choose one keychain style in different colors so each friend gets their own.

  • A cozy reading night. Swap gifts, then spend an hour reading together with hot drinks and snacks.

For more group gift ideas, see our book club gift exchange ideas and Secret Santa gifts for book lovers.

FAQ

What do you get a best friend who loves to read?

Choose something tied to their reading life: a blind date with a book in their favorite genre, a bookmark for their favorite trope, annotation supplies if they tab their books, Kindle accessories if they read on an e-reader, or a matching keychain you can both carry.

What's a good personalized gift for a book lover?

A stationery set with their name on it, a blind date with a book chosen using the books they've loved and disliked, or a copy of your favorite book annotated with notes for them all make personal gifts for readers.

What are good matching gifts for best friends who read?

Matching keychains in different colors, a bookmark set you split between you, coordinating stationery bundles in each of your favorite colors, or two blind dates in the same genre that you open together.

How do I buy a book for a friend without getting one they've read?

A blind date with a book helps. When ordering, list a few books your friend loved and a few they didn't, and share a link to their reading profile if it's public and up to date, so the book can be chosen with their history in mind.

What is Friendsmas?

Friendsmas is a holiday celebration with friends, often a party or gift exchange held before or after family holidays. Bookish friend groups often swap books, trope-themed gifts, or blind dates with a book.

Find the Perfect Book for Your Best Friend

Ready to surprise your reading bestie? Browse MIL's Blind Date With a Book collection in nine genres, each packed with handmade bookish accessories by our family-run shop.

 

Subscribe to our emails

Be the first to know about new collections and special offers.