The best gifts for romantasy readers celebrate the things they love most about the genre: the yearning, the magic, the morally grey love interest, and the slow burn that finally catches fire. A mystery romantasy read, a set of enemies to lovers stickers, or a fairy tale bookmark will land far better than a random fantasy novel they may already own.
Romantasy, the blend of romance and fantasy, is still one of the most talked about genres on BookTok. That also makes it one of the hardest to shop for. Romantasy readers tend to binge entire series, preorder new releases, and keep a TBR that could stretch into the next century. Odds are, they already have the book you were thinking of buying.
This guide focuses on gifts that work alongside their bookshelf instead of competing with it, including tons of fun, bookish stuff that will definitely get your readers excited!
Best Overall: A Romantasy Blind Date With a Book
A Blind Date With a Book is a wrapped, mystery book chosen for the reader, so they get the thrill of a surprise and the joy of a new romantasy read in one gift. Our Blind Date With a Book comes with a Romantasy genre option, and every bundle is hand-wrapped and paired with handmade reading accessories.
The best part for gift givers is that you do not have to guess what they have already read. After ordering, you can contact us with a link to the reader's Goodreads, StoryGraph, or another reading list, and the pick is chosen with that list in mind so it can skip books they have already read. There’s a basic and a deluxe version as well, each with its own set of extra bookish goodies.
Why the Deluxe is worth it for romantasy fans
Sprayed edges are a big deal in the romantasy world. Those coloured, patterned, or gilded page edges turn a book into a shelf centrepiece, and many readers collect them on purpose. Every Blind Date bundle has a chance of including a special edition, hardcover, or sprayed edge book, but the Deluxe Bundle has a higher chance of a sprayed edge edition. For a reader who loves a beautiful shelf, that alone makes the upgrade feel special.
The Deluxe also adds four extras on top of the Basic: a leather heart bookmark, a magnetic bookmark, a scrunchie, and a colour-matched handmade keychain. It turns the gift into a full reading night in a box.
How to order a romantasy Blind Date: choose Basic or Deluxe, select Romantasy as the genre, then email the reader's book list with your order number so the pick can be tailored to them.
Shop the Basic Romantasy Blind Date or Shop the Deluxe Romantasy Blind Date.
Bookmarks for Romantasy Readers
Romantasy series are long, and readers often juggle a few at once. A bookmark with a little magic to it is a gift they will use every single day.
Handmade Beaded Leather Fairy Tale Bookmark
This is the statement bookmark of the guide. A soft blue faux-leather-style tab stamped with "FAIRY TALES" hangs from a handmade strand of purple, red, blue, and pink beads. Celestial star charms, a crescent moon, and a heart-shaped accent dangle from a fine chain. Each one is assembled by hand, so no two are exactly alike. It is a perfect match for readers who love fae courts, enchanted forests, and fairy tale retellings. Shop the Handmade Beaded Leather Fairy Tale Bookmark.
Masquerade Ball Romantic Trope Bookmark Set
Masquerade balls are a romantasy staple: hidden identities, stolen dances, and a stranger who turns out to be the enemy prince. This trope bookmark set leans into that mood, and giving a set means they can mark every book in their current rotation. Shop the Masquerade Ball Romantic Trope Bookmark Set.
Book Boyfriend Hook Bookmark
Every romantasy reader has a fictional love interest they would follow into any war. This pink and silver beaded bookmark has a metal hook that sits inside the book and a charm that reads "Sorry I can't, I have a date with my book boyfriend." Shop the Book Boyfriend Hook Bookmark.
Soda Can Style Romance Trope Bookmarks
A playful, budget-friendly pick shaped like retro soda cans, with romance tropes as the "flavours." They are easy to tuck into a card or pair with a bigger gift. Shop the Soda Can Style Romance Trope Bookmarks.
Romantasy Stickers and Kindle Decor
A lot of romantasy readers do most of their reading on a Kindle, especially during a series binge. Stickers and inserts let them make that device feel as magical as the stories on it.
Assorted Romantasy Sticker Set
Five waterproof matte vinyl stickers in rich black, plum, purple, burgundy, and antique gold: a knight's helmet wrapped in dark purple roses, a dragon curled around an ornate moon, a sealed fantasy love letter, an "Enemies to Lovers" swords and roses design, and a magical reaching-hands design. Each one is custom designed and hand-cut. You can buy the full pack or choose a single design. Shop the Assorted Romantasy Sticker Set.
Romantasy Enemies to Lovers Trope Sticker Bundle Set
Three stickers that say exactly what a romantasy reader is thinking: "Here for the Magic and the Tension," "Give Me Swords and Yearning," and "Enemies to Lovers Enthusiast." Shop the Enemies to Lovers Trope Sticker Bundle.
Dark Fantasy Purple Themed Sticker Bundle
Four gothic die-cut stickers with old books, roses, a snake, and ornate frames, including a design titled "The Midnight Ball." They are sized to work on a Kindle case. Shop the Dark Fantasy Purple Sticker Bundle.
Romantasy Pink Themed Sticker Set
Two small sets that make easy add-ons: one soft and fairytale pink, one moody and masquerade purple. Pick the one that matches their reading mood, or get both for a light and dark pairing. Shop the Romantasy Pink Sticker Set or Shop the Purple Dark Fantasy Masquerade Sticker Set.
Dark Romance Kindle Insert and Accessories Bookish Bundle
A Kindle insert is a printed card that slides into a clear Kindle case behind the device, changing the whole look without any glue. This dark romance bundle pairs a purple striped insert, featuring a skull, crows, roses, and the line "Hot Masked Men Are My Weakness," with matching gothic accessories. It is made for the reader whose romantasy leans dark. Shop the Dark Romance Kindle Bundle.
Rivals to Lovers Academia Romance Trope Kindle Insert
Magic academies and rival students are a beloved corner of romantasy. This insert brings that dark academia rivalry to their Kindle. Check which Kindle model they own before ordering. Shop the Rivals to Lovers Academia Kindle Insert.
Wearable Gifts for Romantasy Fans
Some of the best romantasy gifts are the ones they can carry off the page. These handmade pieces are subtle enough for everyday wear but still feel like a nod to their favourite worlds.
Handmade Glass Heart Drop Luxury Dangle Earrings
Translucent red glass hearts above faceted black teardrops, set in ornate gold-tone metal. The red and black pairing has a royal, slightly dangerous feel, like something a fae queen would wear to court. Shop the Glass Heart Drop Earrings.
Silicone Bead Wristlet Keychain
A pink beaded wristlet with rhinestone accents and a gold clasp. It keeps keys handy on the way to the bookstore or library and adds a soft, bookish touch to any bag. Shop the Silicone Bead Wristlet Keychain.
Beaded Flower Keychain
Handmade silicone beaded flowers in pink and cream with a heart-shaped clasp and leather tassel. For readers who picture themselves wandering a spring court garden, this one clips onto a tote or book bag. Shop the Beaded Flower Keychain.
How to Pick the Right Gift for Their Kind of Romantasy
Romantasy is a big tent. A reader who loves cozy fae courtships may not want the same gift as someone who reads blood oaths and morally grey villains. Take a peek at their shelf, their Kindle, or their reading app, then use this guide.
For fae and fairy tale lovers
Look for whimsy, florals, and celestial details. The Handmade Beaded Leather Fairy Tale Bookmark and the Romantasy Pink Themed Sticker Set both fit, and the Beaded Flower Keychain carries the look onto their bag.
For dragon rider and war college fans
These readers love high stakes, rivalries, and battle scenes. The Assorted Romantasy Sticker Set has a dragon and moon design and a knight's helmet, and the Rivals to Lovers Academia Kindle Insert suits the academy setting.
For dark romantasy readers
Think deep purples, roses, daggers, and masks. The Dark Romance Kindle Insert and Accessories Bundle, the Dark Fantasy Purple Themed Sticker Bundle, and the Purple Dark Fantasy Masquerade Sticker Set all match a darker shelf. The red and black Glass Heart Drop Earrings complete the look.
For enemies to lovers devotees
If every book they recommend involves two people who start out wanting to kill each other, go straight for the Romantasy Enemies to Lovers Trope Sticker Bundle Set and the "Enemies to Lovers" sticker in the Assorted Romantasy set.
For the reader who has read everything
This is where the Romantasy Blind Date With a Book shines. Share their reading list when you order, and they get a new romantasy pick wrapped as a surprise. Choose the Deluxe if they love collecting beautiful editions, since it has a higher chance of a sprayed edge book.
FAQ
What is romantasy?
Romantasy is a blend of romance and fantasy. The love story is just as important as the magic, quest, or war happening around it. Common elements include fae courts, dragons, magic schools, rival kingdoms, and tropes like enemies to lovers and forced proximity.
What is a good gift for someone who loves romantasy books?
A romantasy Blind Date With a Book is one of the best options, because it gives them a new book in their favourite genre without you having to guess what they have read. Romantasy themed bookmarks, enemies to lovers stickers, and Kindle inserts also make great gifts for readers who already own a lot of books.
What are sprayed edges, and why do romantasy readers love them?
Sprayed edges are page edges that have been coloured, patterned, or printed with designs, so the book looks striking on a shelf. Many romantasy releases come in special editions with sprayed edges, and collectors seek them out. Our Deluxe Blind Date With a Book has a higher chance of including a sprayed edge edition than the Basic.
What is the difference between the Basic and Deluxe Blind Date With a Book?
Both include a new mystery book, handmade bookmarks, a pen, a highlighter, annotation tabs, and tea. The Deluxe adds 2 more stickers, a second tea bag, a leather heart bookmark, a magnetic bookmark, a scrunchie, and a colour-matched handmade keychain. It also has a higher chance of a sprayed edge edition.
Can I make sure they don't get a book they've already read?
Yes, you can help. After ordering, email the reader's Goodreads, StoryGraph, or another web-accessible reading list along with your order number. The book is chosen with that list in mind. Without a list, a duplicate cannot be ruled out.
What are good small gifts for romantasy readers?
For under $15, try the Romantasy Enemies to Lovers Trope Sticker Bundle Set, the Masquerade Ball Romantic Trope Bookmark Set, or the Rivals to Lovers Academia Kindle Insert. All three are easy to tuck into a card or stocking.
Send them on a blind date with their next favourite romantasy
If you only get one thing from this list, make it a romantasy Blind Date With a Book. Pick Basic or Deluxe, choose Romantasy, and let the surprise do the rest.
0 comments